The Critical Papers series

The Approach Under Its Own Law
AFS doesn’t get a pass just because it’s the approach doing the diagnosing. This series turns the same scrutiny back on AFS itself — not as a private audit, but built in the open, in response to the critique the Open for Review page kept generating. Six papers so far, each testing a different way the approach could be wrong: bounded, incoherent, misapplied, borrowed, canonized, or simply never tested at all before being invoked. Read them on Open for Review, where the conversation that shaped them is still visible.